cross-posted from: https://lemmy.ml/post/55083659

The question of when to support an imperfect faction and to what extent is perhaps the biggest political question of the modern day. “Faction” here should be understood to mean both parties and organizations, as well as states. Many people have assumptions about what he believed and argued for, but these are sometimes based on incomplete readings of his work, or just picked up from osmosis from other people discussing it.

Obviously, Lenin’s perspective is not dogma, and not necessarily applicable to modern day conditions. However, I consider his analysis insightful, and it is rather nuanced and complex at times, which is why I consider a deep analysis like this to be important.

The way I’ve framed the question is very broad, so I have broken it down into more specific cases:

  1. Should socialists participate in bourgeois elections?

  2. Should socialists support the “lesser evil” or “underdog” in geopolitical affairs?

  3. Should socialists support bourgeois-led national liberation movements?

Due to length, my analysis will be posted in the comments.

[NB: Not all the quotes I cite are continuous, but I have made a good faith effort to represent his positions accurately to the best of my understanding, without cherry picking or proof-texting.]

  • purpleworm [none/use name]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    9
    ·
    7 days ago

    entryism which has led to precisely nothing in 100 years and hundreds if not thousands of attempts across countries.

    If anything, you understate your case here, because it has led to many things, mostly the undermining of various leftist movements.

    Entryist participation in a bourgeois party requires abandoning the truth, because it requires pushing the line that elections can or will lead to socialism, which they have not and never will.

    Running in the election does not require endorsing this position, as far as I know.

    • Awoo [she/her]@hexbear.net
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      7
      ·
      7 days ago

      Running in the election does not require endorsing this position, as far as I know.

      In any bourgeois party in the world you’ll be purged if you’re advocating against for revolution and saying that elections won’t achieve what people want. In the US I guess they can’t purge you but they will cut support and run other candidates against you. So you may as well not be in their party anyway.