- cross-posted to:
- technology@lemmy.world
- reddit@lemmy.world
- news@lemmy.world
- cross-posted to:
- technology@lemmy.world
- reddit@lemmy.world
- news@lemmy.world
I went to my two bookmarks today which is the only real reason I go there anymore (FGoS and FGF)… Bounced to the homepage to see what was there, this exact post was featured. Almost all of the comments were absolutely shredding Reddit, saying everything we already know to be true, that it’s a fake place filled with bots, the people are exhausted, there’s no real engagement and everybody left there knows it. After reading all that confessions in that thread, makes me seriously wonder why people still go there.
Reddit is just so shit now.
I used to be on there all the time, then they canned all the apps and I found Lemmy. But I still go on there occasionally, where I get almost no engagement on my comments, and what I do get tends to be shitty. I post on here, and I’ll usually get an upvote or two here and there, but over there; nothing. Because bots don’t upvote, I guess. Or I have shitty takes.
Oh bots will up and downvote but it will all be politically motivated.
They’ll downvote the hell out of certain comments while promoting others way above what they are actually worth.
How much of it is real is impossible now to know, so there’s absolutely no point worrying about it.
Recently, like a week ago, I went on Reddit to have a nose and was introduced to a massive warning telling me to log on to read further. I noped out of there in no time. Went back yesterday and the message had disappeared. I think they realised they were biting the hand that feeds them.
Reddit is currently in a massive denial loop. They can’t get rid of the bots because it would affect their ad revenue and also show how few real people post there and be the death knell as users realise. Advertisers would also realise that they’d been overcharged as the numbers they get quoted for reach would be laughable.
The fact that google struck a deal with Reddit and now Google is eating their revenue is hysterical.
I logged on using my desktop browser the other day, and, after a few seconds was met with a half page popup telling me to use the app.
On my desktop.
I couldn’t dismiss the popup. The site thought I was using a mobile browser.
They’ve properly fucked it and I couldn’t be happier for them.
I read and enjoyed your comment, so have an upvote and some engagement.
I appreciate the engagement. Have some in return.
One sub I still check regularly is hit with repost bots once or twice a week, and the mods don’t seem to be paying attention anymore.
They also recently forced you to sign in before you can use old.reddit.com
Just posted about that and saw your comment.
Yeah, they knew they shot themselves in the foot with doing that to the main reddit site. It got changed back, don’t know about old reddit though.
Certainly not because of business decision and being an asshole.
No it’s because they killed almost all of the algorithms available to the user in favor of this shitty “For You” Facebook like feed, most people liked to use the All sort, and now that is completely dead outside of old.reddit, also that’s not including all the shit Reddit has done over the years to cause our exodus to continue since killing the 3rd party apps.
Rookie numbers. Let’s get them higher.
A case where AI is having a positive impact. Hopefully number continues to drop.
Greedy reddit owners have made the site worse over the years for people who actually use it and waged war on third party apps people liked to submit content that led to engagement.
I hate this life cycle of corporate malarkey. I wish customers and staff had a say over company acquisitions and decision making. This presumption that ownership entitles you to destroy an institution built over decades by others is just not good enough.
The issue is public ownership via the stock market that demands share prices must go up no matter what.
Private companies don’t have this problem, but they also typically can’t grow as large as public companies because they have a more limited pool of investment.
You’re touching on a central idea in socialism and communism: collective ownership of the means of production, giving people control over the businesses their work sustains. What you’re describing doesn’t require communism, but existing owners often have little incentive to give up control voluntarily. Its more hassle than benefit to them in a system where its not required. Making it a guaranteed right would generally require legislation or a change in ownership structures.
Fuck reddit. Like, obviously. Wouldn’t be here if I didn’t think so.
But there is an uncomfortable reality that even with the boatloads of FREE labor from mods (in itself a giant problem) reddit was never profitable. By the time they IPOd they were almost a billion in the hole.
Even if you say “lavish salaries” or whatever, it would still be many of hundreds of millions without them.
It sucks but it is what it is. Collective ownership is great when something generates a surplus. At an ongoing loss? Less fun.
You gotta understand that VC fucking sucks, too. If it were realistically as likely to fill the budget gaps by literally any other mechanisms, most companies would take the alternatives. Lowering ad vetting, reddit gold, their short lived crypto, highly unpopular staffing decisions (canning my girl Victoria)… None of this put reddit even close to being in the black.
Wikimedia running ongoing donation drives is the closest alternative, but even that doesn’t come with ownership. Collective ownership can come with the same problems as VC anyways, enough people wanna exit their ownership, they can still drive to an IPO. The additional administrative burden of maintaining a splintered cap table as well becomes an expensive additional burden to an already bleeding organization.
I’m all about collective ownership. I just understand what that entails, and exactly why it’s not always a rose garden. Again, lovely at a surplus. Very painful at a deficit.
Fuck reddit, hands down. Fuck them over and over. They deserved to fold long ago.
Lemmy instances run on charity and FOSS code (also charity). Literally nothing is stopping you or anyone from running an instance as a co-op. ml being a bastion of pure communism STILL doesn’t offer ownership stakes.
So using that objective reality of how the “hardcore Lemmy communists” don’t even have communal ownership of thier communism platforms I think is telling about the realities of ceding ownership of what you’ve wrought by your own charity. There is no law keeping any ml instance from granting equal shares of instance ownerships. It’s not a law problem or even a philosophy problem, it’s simply a people problem (even among the people who do nothing but extoll the virtues of communism day in and day out).
I can’t stress enough how ml instances exemplify with absolutely no hint of fucking irony the “all animals are created equal, but some are more equal than others” when literally nothing external is stopping them from just literally adopting a model of communal ownership.
Or, how you could do it like, tomorrow.
And again, I can’t stress enough: I genuinely really like the idea of communal ownership. It’s just fucking hard when the thing you communally own is a money pit.
Loving your explanation
Yeah, this is what bothers me more broadly. There’s a massive gap between what politicians say they want, what the law actually says and what happens in the real world. It’s mind-boggling how little scrutiny that last part gets.
A tech company might be worth $4 billion on paper, but it also employs 2,000 people and might have taken decades to build with many partners in the national business community. If an overseas buyer can come in, hollow it out and sell it for parts, all those people lose their livelihoods and the nation loses a piece of its history.
Surely the people who built that company and the thousands of customers who rely on it should get some say before the deal goes through.
the owner doesn’t have to sell.
boy howdy are they fucking themselves over there
The fact that spez thought this would end up being a money farm is low key hilarious, tbh
Obligatory “Fuck Spez!”
Greedy little fuck pig.
Fully in the “extract stored value” phase
This is the business level equivalent of training your replacement, lol
Righteous, good, and pure!
Oh so now I was considered as AI?
Two weeks ago instead of reddit I got a message that I was a bot or something so I closed browser, cleared cookies and never went back.
Oh the irony.






