um, the New Yorker is a notorious Putin Asset™
Putin propagandists have now infiltrated the highest echelons of liberal media 😄
lol, just when the American overlords say so. damn, ukraine has been fucked bad… by the Russians AND by the Americans. this madness has to end. stopping financing a proxy war would be a good first step.
Yeah, the people of Ukraine are the victims of this proxy war. Even if the war ends today, millions of people will have their lives ruined forever, and hundreds of thousands have died.
I get a feeling the Russian bourgeoisie might just go ahead and accept whatever proposals there are
At this point, I can’t see how this war can end on western terms politically. There’s just too much invested into it at this point to just stop.
Bourgeoisie betrayal, as usual
Can’t rule that out, but we’ll see what happens. Seems that with Russia having managed to realign trade to the east, and the west going into a recession even the bourgeoisie won’t have much to gain by looking to the west now.
Saber rattling about China will be reemphasized while this piece will be the first in establishing the new narrative that the liberal consensus was always primarily interested in a negotiated peace with Russia and never thought a total Ukrainian victory was possible.
Sure, but ultimately it’s up to Russia to decide whether they stop the war or not. And it has been a theme now that libs make all these hare brained schemes simply assuming that Russia is going to agree to them, then act shocked when Russia doesn’t.
Well, maybe we’ll see some negotiated end to hostilities by the start of next year. It takes time for American media to change public opinion towards that.
The question is what the west can offer at this point that still allows the west to save face. The key demand for Russia is demilitarization of Ukraine and keeping it out NATO, and it would be pretty hard to dress that up as anything but a total Russian victory over the west.
There’s really not much leverage the west has over Russia at this point either. The sanctions failed, and Russia’s military is only getting stronger. Meanwhile, Europe isn’t doing so hot economically and the economy in US isn’t doing much better either. The relative damage to the west is clearly more significant than to Russia. Not to mention that the war is now a major driving factor behind dedollarization and the rise of BRICS which puts the west in a far weaker position geopolitically going forward.
The key demand for Russia is demilitarization of Ukraine and keeping it out NATO, and it would be pretty hard to dress that up as anything but a total Russian victory over the west.
To this day westerners keep painting the Winter War as a Finnish victory because the USSR didn’t annex the whole country, regardless of if they ever wanted to. Don’t underestimate the West’s ability to revise recent history by moving goalposts.
fair point
There’s really not much leverage the west has over Russia at this point either
There’s an option to force more countries into chaos or suicidal attacks, I suppose. Georgia, Armenia, stupid belt, Poland. Perhaps Moldova and Romania. Plus the fuckery in Africa and middle East. If their goal is to stretch out Russian resources, I could see it at least attempted. If the goal is to harm China, then there’s also Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, etc.
Poland and Baltics are most likely to get shoved off a cliff, but fundamental problem that NATO has right now is lack of industrial capacity. These small countries can provide men to be sacrificed, but US is the only major weapons producer in the west, and it’s simply not able to keep up right now. Obviously, US could start developing domestic industry, but that’s going to take years to do.
US is also in a political turmoil now the likes of which have never been seen. The country is very divided internally, and the tensions are rising, and economic situation is worse now than it was during the great depression. This creates a ripe environment for opportunists like Biden and Trump to take charge, and the administrations these clowns run aren’t able to solve the problems US has. Even in regards to the war there’s a lot of infighting because there’s a neocon camp that thinks this is a distraction from China. The worse things get the harder it becomes to justify keeping the war going domestically.
Russia has a huge advantage in this regard because it has a stable government that’s able to do long term planning and the industry that was inherited from USSR that can produce the weapons and ammunition needed to keep the war going.
Never happening within this year. Russia has to play hard ball game this year. Bomb Ukraine to stone age… Otherwise there is no way out.
I think it’s very likely that we’ll see a military collapse in Ukraine if things keep going the way they are. Ukraine is losing trained military personnel at an incredible rate, and you can’t just replace these people with those you kidnap off the street.
I am astonished that Ukraine still has such kind of military personnels that has thwarted the Russian offensive obviously there is an immense amount of Western help which will be disclosed in 20+ years. And by kidnapping everyone on the streets, this proxy war can go for 5+ years.
