whenyellowstonehasitsday

  • 0 Posts
  • 147 Comments
Joined 3 months ago
cake
Cake day: August 14th, 2024

help-circle










  • alright you get one more, then i kind of need to stop wasting my time with you unless you get more entertaining quickly

    it’s the Russian equivalent, you say, except the power dynamic is entirely different and CSTO isn’t expanding. Interesting.

    because nobody wants to join the alliance run by the country most likely to invade you? “russia is too disliked for their alliance to be popular” or “russia is too incompetent to run an effective alliance” is an incredible argument

    why don’t we ask azerbaijan and armenia how their membership is going if you’re confused as to why csto is unpopular?

    Export of Industrial and Financial Capital to exploited Countries to super-exploit for super-profits, like an international Capitalistic relation.

    ohhhhhhh so you mean like sending in pmcs to countries in africa? or setting up debt traps for countries in africa?

    I have explained how and why, your refusal to read is no longer my problem.

    Quite the contrary, your selective reading and blinders mean you can’t be reached with words.

    literally nothing you’ve said has justified nato behaving in an imperialist way, other than your definition of imperialism, which includes russia and china, so good job

    to paraphrase you, “membership expansion isn’t imperialism”, which is the only thing you’ve been arguing over, which is wild when the thing you’re meant to be justifying is that “nato is a protection racket”.

    i don’t think you know what a protection racket is


  • So then why bring it up?

    because it’s the closest equivalent to nato? the us also wouldn’t be allowed to join brics, if that helps de-confuse you.

    Invasion and Imperialism are not the same thing.

    please provide a definition for imperialism that doesn’t include what russia’s doing in ukraine now

    This kinda verges on anti-Russian racism, there’s no analysis of why you believe this.

    says the one who’s just been continuously stating without expounding that nato is a collection of spooky imperialist powers

    You indeed do not know.

    The GDR indeed purged Nazis, as they were attacked by western Germany, which largely retained its Nazis.

    or don’t respond to what i posted that’s cool too i guess

    i think it’s pretty clear you don’t have much of an argument here, given that this started as “nato is a protection racket” and across 6 replies you’ve provided absolutely nothing to support that statement past whinging

    peace


  • Has the US been denied entry into CSTO? Has the CSTO expanded against the will of NATO?

    i don’t think nato cares about csto

    It’s NATO’s fault for consisting of the absolutely most grotesque reaches of Imperialist countries

    russia is literally doing an imperialism right now, but nato is the one with grotesque reaches, okay

    Bzzzt wrong. NATO has been expanding long before.

    lmao because nato predates russia

    and russia started getting into iffy wars basically at its inception

    When and why did Russia start “misbehavin?”

    probably because they’re an imperialist power? i don’t know

    East-Germany purged Nazis

    okay


  • NATO was formed to be anti-USSR, after the collapse of which the Russian Federation tried to join NATO, and was denied.

    in the same way the us wouldn’t be allowed to join csto

    The RF then complained about NATO expansion, which had not ceased.

    i don’t see how it’s nato’s fault that people are so sick of russia’s shit that they’re signing up to the defensive alliance against them in their droves

    it was provoked by NATO expansion

    nato expansion that existed because of russian land grabs

    nato isn’t the warsaw pact. they aren’t sending in tanks to force people to be a part of their alliance.

    this is just you doing the thing you accused me of doing by refusing to consider externalities

    NATO didn’t start after 2022

    russia didn’t start misbehavin’ after 2022 either

    many of its leaders were Nazi officers

    east germany was part of the warsaw pact, and had plenty of ex-nazis in its ranks

    the reason you can’t draw a line from that to today is because the ussr folded like a cheap suit 30 years ago

    it has always been a way to exert Western supremacy

    you’re just kind of saying things now