I ate a ban (actually three) for reasons wholly unknown some time ago and was wondering: Is there usually a process for appealing these things, or at least getting an explanation? The reasons in the mod log aren’t very helpful. Some instances have a clear “contact us” section, but if not what do you do? Is there anything to do? For the record the instances are quokk.au (the one that prompted me to post this), Lemmy.ca and Lemmy.blahaj.zone.

  • sbird@retrofed.com
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    7
    ·
    edit-2
    10 小时前

    Looking at your modlog, I see many comments from about a year ago and back where you were transphobic (“transwomen have a biological advantage and are winning championships” is misinformative, yes there should be debate e.g. to what degree should HRT be needed to permit trans athletes, but most championships are still won by cispeople because transpeople are in the minority, they are not “dominating women’s champiomships”) and calling people “retarded”, which is not very nice at all! If this is still the case, then you are a bigot (a person who discriminates those based on their identity).

    There is also a lot of tangents towards irrelevant topics in order to invigorate fiery debates (which broke off-topic and “be civil” rules of those communities), and for some reason you stated that “Britain should not have participated in WWII” under a post regarding how Farage (far-right racist guy in Britain) is echoing the exact same thing, which is certainly not a good look. When others criticised that, actually, beating the Nazis is a net positive (all wars are bad, but allowing appeasement to go on is also very bad, genocide is bad!), you fought against that, again, a very bad look. The ban reasons of supporting fascism and dismissing genocide are likely genuine if you still behave this way! (Perhaps you don’t, but it really seems like you do…)

    • NoneOfUrBusiness@fedia.ioOP
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      7 小时前

      First I want to note that none of these are likely to be the reason for the bans because they’re too old. I doubt anyone was randomly looking through my

      Looking at your modlog, I see many comments from about a year ago and back where you were transphobic (“transwomen have a biological advantage and are winning championships” is misinformative, yes there should be debate e.g. to what degree should HRT be needed to permit trans athletes, but most championships are still won by cispeople because transpeople are in the minority, they are not “dominating women’s champiomships”)

      That makes more sense in context. My point wasn’t “transwomen have a biological advantage and are winning championships,” but rather “to what degree transwomen have a biological advantage in championships is a question that needs to be addressed.” I later learned that the answer is “not much,” but IIRC these messages were me defending the question rather than any particular answer.

      and calling people “retarded”, which is not very nice at all!

      Yeah I’m gonna own this one. This isn’t a word I use often, but I do think it’s okay to call people retarded as long as one is punching up rather than down.

      There is also a lot of tangents towards irrelevant topics in order to invigorate fiery debates (which broke off-topic and “be civil” rules of those communities), and for some reason you stated that “Britain should not have participated in WWII” under a post regarding how Farage (far-right racist guy in Britain) is echoing the exact same thing, which is certainly not a good look

      Uh… I didn’t say that? I said that participating in WWII wasn’t good for Britain, which it wasn’t. I think the Allies murder-suiciding the Axis was just about the best way WWII could’ve ended, but it did lose Britain its empire, force 15 years of wartime rationing and put it into debt for decades to come. The decision to enter WWII was by far an absolute moral good but bad for Britain (which lost its status as a superpower out of the affair), was and remains my position. To be clear I think it’s a good thing that Britain lost its empire and was relegated to second tier power status, but that’s not the question being asked.

      Which is to say: If these are the reasons I got banned then I’ll eat the bans, but I doubt they are.

      • sbird@retrofed.com
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        1
        ·
        7 小时前

        Still, you definitely have a habit of directing conversation towards very off-topic and fiery hot debates from what I can see, and perhaps you said something particularly bad that was the last straw.

        The modlog does show that, in the past, you were a bit of a bigot, maybe not intentionally, but those statements are discriminatory towards trans athletes and misinformative. It’s like defending the question of whether white people are being “replaced” in Britain, claiming that you were not defending any particular answer doesn’t help your case!

        Again, you were arguing that WWII was bad for Britain, and like Farage (do you really want to be like that smelly old guy? The guy who was scared of a literal bin from outer space?), it implies that Britain should not have joined WWII. Even if benefit of doubt is given that it is not your intention, if you do believe that it was a moral net positive for Britain to join WWII, why argue against it, indirectly or not?

        Almost certainly, you were banned for a valid reason. I do not think that you would be banned for no reason. From my understanding, the moderators of .ca and .blahaj.zone do not have a history with that sort of stuff. I am not familiar with quokk.au’s moderation history though

  • 2ndDegreeOWO@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    16
    ·
    20 小时前

    Some instances have a clear “contact us” section, but if not what do you do?

    If they don’t have any clear way to contact, you just sign up for a different instance and leave that one behind.

    Even if they do have a ‘contact us’, the likelihood of getting a ban reversed is extremely low.

    If you get banned from an instance, there’s no point in trying to fight it. Just time to start shopping for a new instance.

  • TootSweet@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    8
    ·
    20 小时前

    With regard to the “for reasons wholly unknown” part, have you looked through the modlog to find a reason? (The comment on the admin action, I mean.)

    • NoneOfUrBusiness@fedia.ioOP
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      5
      ·
      20 小时前

      Yeah. I got one “bigotry,” one “fash” and one “fascism and genocide apologia.” Which is fucking weird because I’ve never said fascist things and I’ve definitely never apologized for genocide, but more relevantly to the question it doesn’t let me know what I actually said or did. At the very least it’d be nice to know that (and therefore whether I’m in the wrong or the bans are bullshit).

          • imeansurewhynot@sh.itjust.works
            link
            fedilink
            arrow-up
            5
            ·
            19 小时前

            Okay, weird. I don’t see them. In the post body or in the comments?

            You mean you don’t understand what about your comments was bigotry or fascism or whatever?

            • NoneOfUrBusiness@fedia.ioOP
              link
              fedilink
              arrow-up
              5
              ·
              19 小时前

              I might’ve misunderstood you. If you were talking about the comments the admins left when they banned me, they’re “bigotry,” “fash” and “fascism and genocide apologia.” If you meant the comments I left that got me banned, there are none. I have no mod actions from the relevant time periods other than bans themselves; my mod log from that timeframe is basically sparkling clean.

              Edit: If you want to see for yourself.

              • imeansurewhynot@sh.itjust.works
                link
                fedilink
                arrow-up
                5
                ·
                19 小时前

                Yea, I meant your comments. Looks like your post history is strongly political, so an admin probably took particular offense one day while scrolling and banned you everywhere they are able, which is pretty common.

                And since it’s an admin ban, the only “appeal process” is directly messaging the admin who banned you for personal reasons, so an appeal doesn’t seem worth it.

                • Rose@piefed.social
                  link
                  fedilink
                  English
                  arrow-up
                  3
                  ·
                  edit-2
                  12 小时前

                  One thread that preceded NoneOfUrBusiness’s ban from the lemmy.ca instance involved China being described as fascist, for reasons that included ethnic cleansing, but NoneOfYourBusiness appeared to dismiss or minimize that characterization.

                  A thread that preceded the blahaj instance ban (and seemingly the quokk ban) involved NoneOfUrBusiness seemingly trolling about alt text and repeatedly dismissing the notion of 4chan being fascist.

  • Necrifyre@piefed.blahaj.zone
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    5
    arrow-down
    2
    ·
    20 小时前

    for reasons wholly unknown

    There is almost always a certain reason. Come on now. You’re being dishonest.

    • NoneOfUrBusiness@fedia.ioOP
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      20 小时前

      Two of the three say “fascism” and one says “genocide apologia,” and well I’ve never done the former and definitely never done the latter. Besides, if any of the two were true I’d probably be banned from places where I’m more active. I don’t get the impression quokk.au is more anti-fascist than, say, dbzero. In any case it’d be nice to go from vague accusations to an actual “you got banned because of this thing you did.” Also I looked for comment deletions around the time of the ban, but no bueno, so I’d be forced to conclude that I said something so offensive as to get banned but not offensive enough to be deleted.

      • Necrifyre@piefed.blahaj.zone
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        1
        ·
        7 小时前

        And sure enough, someone got a hold of your post history. Then again, anyone could see the modlog so it isn’t like it’s a mystery. Dude, just eat the loss and move on. You can’t just be going around saying stupid shit and not have repercussions over it. And no, before you ever say it, you don’t have a right to free speech because the Fediverse is not the government. You break a rule or two, it is anyone’s discretion to hand out a punishment as fitting to the violation.

        I think your biggest regret now is posting in places where you think people can’t see what you’ve said.