I saw this post over on Reddit, and it caught me completely off guard.
> I love playing Pathfinder, and when I’m a player I love fights, because I get to experience my character’s personality in an actual situation and with a bunch of gameplay stuff attached (I can shout cool attack names for exemple). > > But when I’m the GM, I loathe fights. I know my players want and enjoy them, but I find them boring. I can’t get attached to the NPCs because they often get destroyed (I mean, that’s kinda what antagonists are for), so I’m not exactly roleplaying them ; I also have to remember a couple of sheets each time (and I want to avoid using the same sheets because challenge and novelty are good) ; I don’t want to have my players being idle while I play “my” turns because the situation ain’t about me (as in “my characters aren’t the protagonists”) so I often end up pressuring myself into rushing the NPCs turns… > > But I love building the encounters, think about the NPCs’ strategies, combat drills etc… But when comes the time to hit my friends in the face, it’s hard to feel… involved ^^" > Do you have any advice for a fellow GM ?
This brought into focus and brought voice to something that I’ve kind of felt was sitting under the more general PF online community, but that I couldn’t quite articulate or confirm: The idea that the GM’s role at the table is limited to setting up bowling pins for everyone else to knock down. I don’t get the same vibes from other game communities – in no small part because the directly comparable games are D&D 5e and 5.5e, where the communities are incredibly broad – but it feels omnipresent on the Paizo forums, and on r/Pathfinder2e in particular.
It sounds incredibly tedious to set up encounters of rampaging killbots, whose only goal is to kill wave after wave of wandering adventurer until their kill limit is reached. Especially when you’ve already decided in advance that this particular wave of wandering adventurer is the one that will actually survive and dismantle you.
“There’s no point in roleplaying these NPCs because they don’t matter, and only exist to be cut down” is backward logic. The poster here is the one who has decided that these NPCs don’t matter, and that they have no other goals in life than to engage in suicide-by-adventurer, and the end result is that they’re not invested in these characters at all. This GM has not imbued these characters with a drive to live, and so their actions are going to be those of semi-optimized kamikazi creatures, which is going to get boring fast.
I admit, I am not always the best at treating my own combat NPCs any differently. I often find the role of GM to be overwhelming, and I do not trust my internalized sense of what to do in the moment, leaving me leaning on pre-planned strategies that result in structured encounters and suicide-by-adventurer. But it’s not because I’ve decided in advance that that’s what these NPCs would want for themselves, or that that’s all their role in this world is. It’s because game management causes me to short circuit.
Combat becomes so much more interesting when the enemy NPCs have a sense of self-preservation. Whenever I treat them like people with conflicting loyalties – to whoever has placed them between the PCs and themselves, and to their own life, for instance – I almost always end up with more interesting encounters. My enemies become less predictable, and start using the enviornment to their advantage. They take cover. They hide. They engage in sneak attacks and skirmishing. It encourages me to roll for morale, and allows for the PCs to route the enemy and force a retreat, rather than being forced to engage in extended periods of artisanal murder. And I have a lot of fun with that. My players do, too.
But that’s just me and my table. What about you guys? How do you have fun as GM during combats?
@kichae For #pf2e specifically, there’s usually a special action, or combination of actions, that the enemy creature has that make it unique. What I try to do is attempt to execute that action/ combo ASAP, so the players have a “WTF just happened?” moment. Then watch them scramble to avoid/ negate the unique ability. Combat was fun if they manage to outsmart the critter. Combat isn’t fun if the critter never gets to show off its thing.
Also I’m just always trying out new things with the mechanics and the battle map, to keep things interesting for myself. What if map is mostly submerged? What if victory condition is something other than “enemy HP=0” (i.e. “execute three Very Hard DC skill checks on specific locations within 8 rounds”)? What if enemy reinforcements appear after 3 rounds? What if some enemies can be persuaded to switch sides? What if visibility is heavily obscured? Etc.
> Hostile Architecture said: > > What if some enemies can be persuaded to switch sides?
Oh, that one sounds fuuuun!
Very loosely related: I was running Forge of Fury for my table at one point last year; I’d done a quick conversion to PF2e, but I often run the game somewhat loosely, and adopt features or systems from other or older games. One thing I like to do when NPCs have no reason to have any particular feelings about the party showing up is roll an attitude check.
So, the party enters the Dwarven stronghold that’s currently occupied by Duergars, and the module expects this to be a sneaky combat encounter against enemies that can cast Invisibility and use ranged attacks. But I have no in-game reason for these characters to be hostile. They’re explorers, the party are explorers, no one has specific claim to the territory, etc. So, I roll the attitude check, and these blue-skinned little pests turn up Helpful.
So anyway, the party now has an entarage of 3 Duergars. They’ve been around for over a year now, and I don’t think they’re going anywhere.


