• Johnny_Arson [she/her]@hexbear.net
    cake
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    80
    ·
    4 days ago

    It’s one of the biggest criticisms communists have against Stalin and his most terrible mistake, why do you think that support dried up after that year?

    All communists I know are pretty open about that.

    You really wanna compare scores here and compare this with all the genocides conducted by the west that include the one your meme alludes to.

        • Alaskaball [comrade/them, any]@hexbear.net
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          44
          ·
          4 days ago

          A realpolitik roll of the dice political play, imo, to create a crack in the British empires colonial holdings by at best creating an independent socialist bloc aligned spearhead into the heart of Europe’s colonies in west Asia and north Africa, and at tepid a neutral non-aligned independent nation, to preempt the capitalist powers plans to eventually decolonize the region in their own favorable terms.

          I still really wish I could access the still locked away archives on this and other topics because there’s still pieces missing in the puzzle to the whole picture of Stalin’s end life and the last years of his era.

          • TheLastHero [he/him]@hexbear.net
            link
            fedilink
            English
            arrow-up
            38
            ·
            4 days ago

            yeah, people forget now that the early labor Zionists like Ben-Gurion called themselves socialists and were very energized to wage an armed struggle against British colonialism. The conflict was incredibly embarrassing and untenable for the British, and Uncle Joe wanted to drive the knife into this dying empire and didn’t mind the risk of collatoral damage. Also, European Jews were illegally immigrating to Palestine in huge numbers to “join the cause”, regardless of soviet bloc support in addition to many others supporting the cause financially in especially in the US, so if you really wanted to start trying to ascribe responsibility to the USSR for existence of state of Israel it’s not so simple. Most post war Europeans were happy to let the Zionists do whatever ethnic cleansing they needed in Palestine to pretty much free them from the burden of caring for a extra few million Jewish refugees and needing to do any self - reflection about their own nation’s role in collaborating with Nazism.

  • Awoo [she/her]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    37
    ·
    4 days ago

    I became hyperfixated on this topic for a while and dived into a lot of Russian language stuff including archives. I came to a few conclusions about it.

    1. The USSR did this because it wanted to end the British Mandate and weaken the empire, which was successful. This was Molotov’s idea.

    2. After this success, they were willing to continue relations so long as Israel didn’t fuck around.

    3. This turned around very quickly when the Doctor’s Plot was announced:

    • 13 January 1953 - Doctor’s Plot announced

    • 19 January - Sharett condemns this as an anti-Jewish campaign in the Knesset and threatened to raise it internationally

    • 24 January - Soviet Foreign Ministry advised against taking diplomatic action against Israel in internal documents

    • 9 February - A bomb explodes at the Soviet diplomatic mission in Tel Aviv

    • 10 Feb - Israel condemns this attack and sends an apology

    • 12 Feb - Vyshinsky informs Israeli envoy that the USSR is severing diplomatic relations


    So what happened with the Doctor’s Plot? Well my take is that it was cooked up as some sort of excuse to go after zionists in the USSR. In 1952 Israel had requested that the USSR open up emigration channels for Soviet Jews to migrate to Israel, the USSR took this as interfering in its internal affairs. I suspect the Doctor’s Plot was either a real plot to kill Soviet officials or it was cooked up as an excuse to grab zionists that the Soviets were certain were working as agents within the USSR on behalf of Israel. This is conjecture on my part though.

    The position that the USSR was not happy about zionists interfering internally is expressed in this Gromyko memo: https://docs.historyrussia.org/ru/nodes/277601-zapiska-pervogo-zamestitelya-ministra-inos*removed*h-del-sssr-a-a-gromyko-generalnomu-sekretaryu-tsk-vkp-b-predsedatelyu-soveta-ministrov-sssr-i-v-stalinu-23-fevralya-1952-g

    All of the other documents for this can be found in this book, a number of which point out suspicions of agents and the like: https://djvu.online/file/IZF5LJoKR38WA

    Some of the ones that should be read are (numbered documents, not page numbers):

    43 (1944)

    51 (Litvinov, 1945)

    74 and 77 (March–April 1947)

    91 (Vavilov conversation, September 1947)

    95 (Molotov’s secret telegram, September 1947)

    99–100 (October 1947)

    102 (Sultanov assessment, November 1947)

    (but honestly if i were a historian or researcher I would probably read this entire book of documents cover to cover)

    You can do this pretty easily by copy+pasting the page into google translate’s image feature with ctrl+v, it’s pretty reliable and very readable these days.

    Tagging some people below that might be interested: @Johnny_Arson@hexbear.net @casskaydee@hexbear.net

      • Awoo [she/her]@hexbear.net
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        16
        ·
        edit-2
        4 days ago

        I wanna add to my conjecture that the point on the Doctor’s Plot not being antisemitism but rather antizionism comes from seeing a bunch of comments within some of those documents, notably that officials mention many times that good organisations should be funded within the USSR when they do not contain zionism, but they are extremely wary of the ones with zionism.

        For example Document 36 ( begins two thirds of the way down page 95 of the book):

        This very clearly indicates what I mean about internal assessments of zionism in organisations and supporting orgs that do not have it (Levant Publishing House) vs the orgs that do. That’s not antisemitism, that’s antizionism.

        This makes me believe that the Doctor’s Plot itself and the spin that it is antisemitism in the USSR is totally incorrect and the usual framing of antizionism as antisemitism.

  • Krinkil2705@lemmygrad.ml
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    12
    ·
    3 days ago

    Actually, you can ask us and you will receive an answer.

    But from what I heard, Global Northerners were banned from asking about where Israel getting most of its equipment from in 2026.

  • Yllych [any]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    40
    ·
    4 days ago

    Watching the USSR send arms to israelwalter-yell

    watching the USSR split with Tito and end support for Greek communists walter-shock

    Tbf all our enemies had beaucoup bux from Marshall plan money, whereas Soviet union had to rebuild from Berlin to Moscow. It is good to account for these as some of the Soviet mistakes, even with historical context so we can sharpen ourselves for when it is our turn.

  • TUMBLE_BUS [none/use name]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    34
    arrow-down
    1
    ·
    4 days ago

    Yes this is one of the biggest Ls the Soviet Union ever took. I’m pretty sure even the most ardent USSR defenders will tell you that, I doubt even Grover Furr would defend this (or maybe he would, that guy is weird).

  • Muad'Dibber@lemmygrad.ml
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    9
    ·
    edit-2
    3 days ago

    While the early USSR (and Lenin especially), correctly identified Israel as a settler-colonial project, the Holocaust in the 1930s-40s made the USSR reconsider its support for Israel as a nation state. It was incorrect, and was quickly rectified, but its important to keep in mind the effect that the exposure of nazi germany’s extermination campaign, with all its death and slave-labor camps, had on the psychology of the anti-imperialist bloc.

    The USSR also fought a secret war against Israel in 1970, and supported Egypt.