Certified hater.

For writing related content, see my other account: ComicalMayhem@literature.cafe.

any/all

  • 361 Posts
  • 690 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: July 5th, 2023

help-circle



  • All good yo, no biggie. Hope your weekend is better than your week! I genuinely appreciate you taking the time to write this review, it’s rather helpful.

    Re: Airships. Oh fuck you’re right, I completely forgot about that. I’m not even sure the premise of the initiation drop-in works with the airships they have, unless like, they’re getting booted out or something. I’ll have to sit on that, either do some retconning (i.e rewrites), or make it a plot point later.

    Re: Tense is my weakest aspect. I keep fucking it up (_ _。)

    Re: Key. Absolutely fair point, I’ll have to work that in somehow.

    Re: Chapter end. Hey, I never promised it was good fanfiction. Matter of fact, I specifically stated otherwise. Fuck the laws of narrative, I am the narrative! Also the Teto appearance is because I like Teto as a character; her team involves Miku and Neru, two other vocaloids, and a third completely unrelated person because I’m a vocaloid fan larper and only know those three. I was considering adding parts about the planned other two characters of Haru’s team, but it ended up as a side story (WIP, will be put here when done). Mainly because the focus of the story is Haru and Yusha, while the other two are more or less random OCs (one from me {also an ffxiv character} and the other from my yuri consultant). I might eventually work them in to the story more concretely, but the main characters are Haru and Yusha. As for the chapter overall being kinda not much, I mean fair. I kind of struggled on how to get Haru to find her banner while also setting up character stuff (If you want the details, I’ll include them below in a spoiler tag), but it ended up falling flat all around I think, with just her running amok the entire chapter. Not really sure what I was doing/thinking. Then again… taps sign that says shitty fanfiction. I mean, fucking Teto is in the story. Lol.

    The truth is, though, that I’m not much of a long-form author. Most of the things I’ve written have, on average, been like at most 4 pages. I think the longest piece of short form I’ve written extended to about 14 pages? I’d have to double check. Anyways the point is that this is my second foray into long form content (my first foray is absolute dog shit, like it sucks, badly, but hey 200+ pages!). So, I’m liable to fumble around a lot and not have things quite on a leash, especially since I’m more or less a garden author, which means I just start writing and writing and write into a fog until the story is done dragging me where it wants to.

    Edit: Also I’m pretty sure that I wrote most of the beginning chapters without any structure, which is to say I was just writing, not focusing on making good break points between each chapter. Chapter format came after the fact, which is also something I’m not great at.

    Plot points revolving Haru

    Haru is going to be kind of bad at fighting, relying on her semblance and aura too much. The idea is that her semblance uses up her aura, giving her essentially observation haki but at the cost of a much weaker aura than normal when active. It’s effective and gives her a good edge in combat when it works. The downside is that if her aura is depleted or low, she ends up in a very dangerous spot and unable to fight effectively (or at all), sort of like a glass cannon. Combine that with her shitty movement techs, she’s not particularly good in a fight, and this sort of failure as a huntress is only going to be worsened by the fact that she’s appointed leader. Character development!

    The way to look at this that makes me look good is to say that this chapter was supposed to emphasize her flaws but I kind of fumbled at it.

    The other way to look at this is to know that I more or less threw stuff at the wall to give her room to develop. I do have plans to address both these flaws that make her shit at combat (one is, imo, kind of epic. the other is just a reference but also cool imo), as well as a more emotional/character defining arc that gets her to realize her worth or have confidence in herself and abilities / grow as a leader and develop skills in strategy.

    Also, Yusha’s always been a more compelling character for me. Granted, they’ve existed in three fictions so far, but in all 3 I’ve had more to work with with Yusha (this the third, the first a short form smut story, the second a failed attempt at a long form story in a different, grittier universe). That being said, “more to work with” doesn’t mean a whole lot. Haru got “you can do whatever you want with her smile emoji” and Yusha got “uhhh here’s this thing that’s technically canon in the ffxiv universe and applies to my character, there’s that I guess”.










  • Re; Yellow trailer’s fight choreography and ending. I’m actually of the opposite opinion lol; I though the fights were more or less ok, but we’ve seen in other trailers (and even in that one) people flying around all over the place and executing insane, unreal maneuvers. Meanwhile, the fight with the malachite twins felt so low profile in comparison. I can appreciate the footwork and movements (esp when she takes out the second twin); don’t get me wrong, the animation and choreography are great, it just feels out of sync with the other trailers and other parts of the fight. As for the ending, I actually really like it. It pretty quickly establishes Ruby’s and Yang’s relationships, and Ruby’s personality as well. It’s a cute moment if nothing else.

    Re: the lore. They had no clue what they were doing with the story when they launched the trailers. As much as I love and miss Monty and his work, he and the others had no plan. In Red, they put Ruby in front of a grave because they thought it would look cool, with no plan for why she’s in front of it; someone suggested it to be her mom as a throwaway comment and the authors just said “yeah that’s cool.” I mostly consider the trailers to be all pseudocanon as a result.


  • Yeesh, didn’t realize Before the Dawn was so shit. Should I even bother reading it? I was looking to official RWBY books for inspiration/understanding how to write RWBY fiction before deciding to just do my own thing after finishing After the Fall.

    Also gross. Some of the mainstay writers of RWBY and the side stories are pretty obviously bad people. A long ass video I once watched on YT about RWBY went into it a bit.




  • Red trailer so good it’s still doing better numbers than entire volumes.

    Yeah that’s fair about Roman and Pyrrha. One of those “die a good character or live long enough to become a bad one” moments.

    Re: The trailers. I agree for all except Yellow trailer. Red is a phenomenal piece of animation, music, and fight choreography, and my favorite trailer. I don’t particularly like White, purely from preference (not a fan of Weiss or her fighting style); the trailer itself is, from a technical perspective, quite good. Black had some story beats in it, which was nice, and Blake’s original fighting style is so good (plus we get Adam the Aura farmer). Yellow… well, I liked the reload animation. The dialogue and character actions are… let’s just say the correct answer to a child suggesting to kiss and make up is not to say ok and lean forward.